Results 1 to 34 of 34

Thread: The builders Day 5

  1. #1

    Default The builders Day 5

    The builders Day 5
    cost.jpg

    It was a warm sunny day. Lucius Tarquinius and Mark Atilius were sitting on a tree stump, catching some rays of sun.
    "Look, Lucius," the caravan driver asked suddenly. "If it's a frontier city, then there should be Gaul and Teuton merchants here, right? I want to bring some souvenirs home and I'm sure we wouldn't find anything like them in our Central Region."
    "Yes, you're right," agreed the architect. "Do you see that town hall over there? Go in that direction and you'll see a marketplace where only Teutons and Gauls trade. But keep in mind that local tribes don't like us Romans. The Teutons are honest guys, they never tell lies. Gauls are the opposite - they never tell the truth. Go alone, I need to give my builders some construction orders."
    Mark Atilius went to the marketplace; he found it really fast. He visited a smith where he looked at some iron knives and other gear, as well as the potter with his decorated clay-ware and a carpenter who made beautiful wooden figurines. When he visited a baker he found out he had left his money bag somewhere in one of the other shops. Atilius hurried back and saw all three merchants who were now talking to each other.
    "Please, excuse me, honorable merchants, but I left my money at one of your shops."
    The merchants looked at each other.
    "The potter is Gaul, of course, but you left your money in the carpenter's shop," the smith told him.
    "By the way, both the smith and the carpenter belong to the same tribe," added the potter.
    "Well, the potter tells the truth," agreed the carpenter. "But you left your money in his shop."
    Mark Atilius thought for a while. "What did Lucius tell me? Teutons never lie, Gauls always lie? How do I know who is Teuton and who is Gaul?" the caravan driver asked himself.

    Task:
    Help the caravan driver find out which tribe each merchant belongs to and where he left his money.

  2. #2

    Default

    ts19
    Cricketswool

    The Potter and Carpenter are both Gaul, aka liars. The Smith is a Teuton. Therefore, the caravan driver left his money in the Carpenter's shop.

  3. #3

    Default

    Smith is a Teuton
    Potter is a Gaul
    Carpenter is a Gaul

    He left his money in the carpenter's shop.

    Chuckles on ts19

    S6-r1 The_Chuck S8-r1 Lanie (night shift) S5-r3 Tyche (night shift) S7-r3 Chuckles (night shift)
    S2-r6 Tommo and rebuild S1-r7 Country (day shift) S5-r7(AEU) Office Space S19-r2 (SE) The Joker

  4. #4

    Default

    The smith is Teuton

    The potter and carpenter are Gauls.

    The money is in the carpenters shop.

  5. #5

    Default

    http://ts20.travian.si
    njasa-croatia

    Smith - Teuton
    Potter - Gaul
    Carpenter - Gaul

    He left his money at the carpenter.

  6. #6
    -New Users- Farmhand
    Join Date
    Mar 2017
    Posts
    5

    Default answer

    The carpenter is gaul, the potter is also gaul and the smith is teuton. money were left in the carpenter's shop.

  7. #7

    Default

    The Potter & The Carpenter are both Gaul
    The Smith is the Teuton

    The Carpenter (Gaul) has the money

    http://ts5.travian.us/spieler.php?uid=7696

    D Bra!n http://ts5.travian.us/

  8. #8
    -New Users-
    Join Date
    Mar 2017
    Posts
    1

    Default

    Smith : Teutons.
    Potter : Gauls.
    Carpenter : Gauls.

    Caravan driver left his money in Carpenter's Shop.

  9. #9

    Default

    Smith: Teuton
    Potter: Gaul
    Carpenter: Gaul
    Money: In the Carpenter's Shop

    --Attack on us3

  10. #10
    -New Users- Farmhand
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    5

    Default Answer

    Potter - gaul
    Smith - teuton
    Carpenter - gaul
    Money is in the carpenter's shop.

    IGN: qqwq
    Server: http://tx3.travian.us/

  11. #11
    -New Users-
    Join Date
    Mar 2017
    Posts
    2

    Default

    The potter and carpenter are Gaul and the Smith is Teuton. The money is in the carpenter's shop.

    leena_d tx3

  12. #12
    Farmhand Winewanker2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2016
    Location
    At work
    Posts
    11

    Default

    The potter cannot be telling the truth about the smith and carpenter being in the same tribe because they do not agree on the location of the money. If the potter is lying then so is the carpenter because he agreed with the potter about tribes. So if the potter is lying then the potter is Gaul which makes the carpenter Gaul for agreeing and that leaves the smith. The smith correctly identified the potter as Gaul which means he is telling the truth about the location of the money. Summary:
    Smith: Teuton
    Potter: Gaul
    Carpenter: Gaul
    Money: In carpenter’s shop

  13. #13

    Default answer

    The potter and the carpenter are Gauls. The smith is a Teuton.

    The carpenter has the gold.

  14. #14
    -New Users-
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    4

    Default answer

    Task:
    Help the caravan driver find out which tribe each merchant belongs to and where he left his money.

    The potter is gaul, the carpenter is gaul and the smith is teuton.

    The carpenter has the money.

  15. #15

    Default

    wupwup ts3.travian.us
    Answer:
    The Smith is a Teuton, the Potter is a Gaul, and the Carpenter is a Gaul. The money is with the Carpenter.

    Reasoning:
    Assume Smith = Teuton -> Potter = Gaul -> Carpenter = Gaul -> Money with Carpenter
    Assume Smith = Gaul -> Potter = Teuton -> Carpenter = Gaul -> Contradiction Potter is lying Teuton

  16. #16

    Default

    Smith - Teuton
    Potter - Gaul
    Carpenter - Gaul

    The money is at the Carpenter's

  17. #17

    Default Answer

    Smith Teuton
    Potter Gaul
    Carpenter Gaul

    It's in the Carpenter's shop.

    The carpenter is definitely lying. If he was telling the truth, the potter would be, meaning all would be teuton. If all were teuton there wouldn't be 2 different answers on where it is. They also can not be all gaul, because the smithy says the potter is gaul. Therefore, the Carpenter and smithy are not from the same tribe because the potter lies, and it's not in the potter's shop; making the smith a teuton because he is telling the truth about the potter being a gaul and the gold being in the carpenter's shop.

    Archdruid (Druid) Server 3

  18. #18

    Default

    Smith = teuton
    Potter = gaul
    Carpenter = gaul

    Carpenter has the money

    marbhen001
    Ts1.travian.us

  19. #19

    Default

    The Potter is a Gual
    The Carpenter is a Gual
    The Smith is a Teuton

    The money bag was left in the Carpenter's Shop.

  20. #20

    Default answer

    Potter is Teuton, smith and carpenter are both Gauls.

    razguz
    ts3.travian.us

  21. #21

    Default The builders Day 5

    The Smith is Teuton

    The Potter and the Carpenter are Gaul.

    Mark Atilius Left his money in Carpenter's shop.


    IGN: Zura

    Game World: http://ts3.travian.us

  22. #22
    Farmhand
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    The Great White North
    Posts
    6

    Default

    Carpenter and Potter are the Gauls and the money is in the Carpenters shop.
    the Smith is the Teuton who was telling the truth from the start


    USX server McFly account

  23. #23

    Default

    The smith is teuton, the potter and the carpenter are gual, the money is in the carpenter's shop

  24. #24
    -New Users-
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    4

    Default Day 5 Answer

    IGN: ikiwiki
    Server: us3

    Smith is teuton
    Potter and carpenter are gaul

  25. #25
    -New Users- Farmhand
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    5

    Default

    the potter and carpenter are both gaul, and the smith is teuton. The money is at the carpenter's shop.

    Casual_Player
    ts3.travian.us

  26. #26
    -New Users-
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    4

    Default Eximus ts1.travian.com - Puzzle day 5

    Smith is Teuton
    Carpenter and potter are Gauls
    Money bag is with Carpenter

    IGN : EXIMUS
    Server : http://ts1.travian.com

  27. #27

    Default Day 5 Challenge

    Teutons are the fastest to attack, so the Smith is a Teuton and The rest of the pack are the lieing thieving Gauls. So listen to the Smith that the Carpenter has the coin purse.

    Also if the Smith is Teuton, then the potter is Gaul and the Carpenter has the coins. If the Potter is Gaul, then the Smith and the Carpenter are not in the same tribe so the Carpenter can only be a Gaul, which would mean he is all lies.

    If the Smith was Gaul, then the Potter would be Teuton. If the Potter is Teuton, then the Carpenter would be the same tribe as the Smith, a Gaul. But the Carpenter claims he does not have the gold, and that a Teuton is telling the truth. Since the Carpenter would have to lie about everything, he could not admit that a Teuton is telling the truth, therefore this case is not possible, and the case above is what happened.

    FireLord101 US3

  28. #28

    Default

    Either way you spin it the carpenter is Gaul. Since he says the potter tells the truth that means the potter is lying, making the potter a Gaul as well, and the smith would then be Teuton. He said that the money is in the carpenter shop so that's where it is.
    Summory:
    Teuton: the smith
    Gaul: the potter and the carpenter
    Location of money: carpenter's shop

    My server: ts5.travian.us
    My account: Vladimire

  29. #29
    -New Users- Farmhand
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    5

    Default Clipster, tx3.us, Day Five

    This works if the smith is teuton, and the other two are gaul. So he left the money at the carpenter's

  30. #30

    Default The Builders Day 5 Lost Wallet

    The smith is teuton, the potter is gaul, and the carpenter is gaul, and he left his money with the carpenter.


    Moag
    tx3/USx

  31. #31
    Villager Muchacho NL's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    111

    Default

    I feel the potter's answer is the hint to where the money actually is, even though he doesn't say it.

    With this info I'd say both Potter and Carpenter are Gaul. The Smith is Teuton.
    The Potter deflects the Gaul part of the Smith with telling Mark the smith and carpenter are of same tribes.
    The carpenter lies about the potter telling him the truth, (if he was Teuton, the smith would be too, and the money being at the potter shop would be a lie) and doubles down with the money being in another shop.

  32. #32

    Default Day 5 challenge

    The money is in the carpenters shop.
    The Smith is a Teuton and the potter and carpenter are Gauls.

  33. #33

    Default

    The money is in the carpenters shop.
    Smith - Teuton
    Potter and carpenter - Gauls

    ts3.travian.us
    IGN : Superbitory

  34. #34

    Default

    Task:
    Help the caravan driver find out which tribe each merchant belongs to and where he left his money.

    Answer:
    Teutons never lie.
    Gauls always lie.

    Smith: Potter is Gaul | Money in carpenterís shop
    Potter: Smith and Carpenter are either Teutons or Gauls
    Carpenter: Potter tells the truth| Money in potterís shop.

    Letís assume that potter is Teuton and tells the truth.
    That means that the Smith and Carpenter are either Teutons or Gauls.
    If they Teutons = they canít lie, but they tell that the money was left in the different shops = impossible solution.
    If they Gauls = they always lie = Smith tells lie (correct), but Carpenter says: Potter tells the truth Ė impossible solution, because in this case it conflicts with the tasks (Gauls always lie).

    So, if both situations are impossible for Potter as Teuton = Potter is Gaul => Smith and Carpenter belong to different tribes.
    Carpenter is Gaul too, because he agrees with the Potter (and therefore tells lie). => only Smith is Teuton, because Potter lied about him (that the Smith belongs to the same tribe as the carpenter)

    So, the only possible solution is:
    Smith is Teuton.
    Potter is Gaul.
    Carpenter is Gaul, Money in his place.




    Winners Day Five
    Each receive 30 Gold

    Tineren
    njasa
    marbhen001
    Firelord101
    Clipster

    If you did not include your server/nick details in your post please can you PM me with the server and account to receive the gold

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •